[Opensource] passwd in cookie

Michael Rimov rimovm at centercomp.com
Sun Oct 13 02:53:22 PDT 2002


<snip> <snip>

> >
> > Well, backtracing the cookie would take significant time, so the login and
> > logout process could slow to a crawl.  Unless you see a way to do it 
> that I
> > don't?  But either way, I guess the same problems apply here as apply 
> to ip
> > addresses.
>I don't agree Mike. If a laptop redials or loses his/her connection
>somehow, the chances are that the physical path to Expresso will not
>change. Usually, the hardware is still the same regardless of the ip
>address.

But this is defeating the point of having a login cookie in the first 
place.  The point of it is to allow instant login over a significant period 
of time. (ex: 90 days).  If the user is a notebook user, they will 
DEFINITELY be switching locations time and time again.  So having the 
functionality of a login cookie becomes a moot point.

[To David H. now]
RE: counter.
I thought of that, but my problem is that I, for example, switch between 
browsers quite often, and thus the system would squeel, and cry 'replay 
attack', when all I did was switch my browser or switch my machine.  I DO 
think it's significantly simpler CPU-wise.  Thinking about it, I guess if I 
switch browsers, I would create a 'gap' in the numbering sequence, and I 
could record that 'gap' on the server's database.  If a cookie presents 
itself with that gap record, then we update it with the latest sequence, 
and remove the 'gap' entry from the internal records.  Could be a source of 
error, but what do you guys think?

                                                 -Mike





More information about the Opensource mailing list